Can you describe the exact car you want—and what you will reject?
Evidence to have: A one-page acquisition brief. Specify Gullwing or Roadster; for Porsche, name the generation and exact Turbo, Turbo S or RS variant. State whether the objective is touring, display, concours participation or another defined use.
A self-assessment against the desk’s proposed framework, not approval of any car. Stop rules apply separately from the total.
1. Can you describe the exact car you want—and what you will reject?
- A — 0: I have a marque, headline model or attractive listing in mind, but little written down.
- B — 2: I know the model and approximate budget, but intended use, specification or originality requirements remain negotiable without clear limits.
- C — 4: I have an approved brief covering exact variant, intended use, acceptable condition and modifications, originality requirements, holding horizon and non-negotiables.
Evidence to have: A one-page acquisition brief. Specify Gullwing or Roadster; for Porsche, name the generation and exact Turbo, Turbo S or RS variant. State whether the objective is touring, display, concours participation or another defined use.
2. Is your budget an all-in expenditure ceiling rather than an asking-price ceiling?
- A — 0: My budget is essentially the advertised price or maximum bid.
- B — 2: I have allowed for some extras, but funding timing, taxes, fees or initial work remain uncertain.
- C — 4: Funding is confirmed, with an approved US-dollar ceiling covering acquisition charges, diligence, transport, applicable taxes and import costs, initial work and contingency. Any foreign-currency exposure has a dated conversion assumption and approval limit.
Evidence to have: A sources-and-uses schedule, not bank statements submitted to this quiz.
For example, RM Sotheby’s Monterey 2026 terms distinguish hammer price, buyer’s premium and additional expenses; the winning bid is not the entire acquisition bill. Check the terms of the actual sale rather than applying a generic fee percentage. (rmsothebys.com)
3. Who can approve the purchase, sign the agreement and release funds?
- A — 0: The principal is enthusiastic, but the approval route is unclear.
- B — 2: The decision-makers are known, but spending limits, purchasing entity or payment authority remain unsettled.
- C — 4: The buyer or purchasing entity, authorised signatory, expenditure limits, payment approvers and escalation process are documented.
Evidence to have: An approval record. For a private collector, a concise written decision can suffice; for a family office, identify who approves the car, the total expenditure and any exceptions separately.
4. Are you prepared to pay for independent evidence—even if the conclusion is “do not buy”?
- A — 0: I expect the seller or selling intermediary to provide all necessary assurance.
- B — 2: I will commission some checks, but scope, fees, responsibilities or commercial relationships are unclear.
- C — 4: I have approved a buyer-side diligence budget, defined deliverables and cancellation terms, and obtained written disclosure of relevant seller relationships, referral payments and success fees.
Evidence to have: Engagement letters separating research, mechanical inspection, authentication, legal advice and import advice.
Do not assume a helpful selling specialist represents the buyer: RM Sotheby’s Monterey 2026 conditions identify its auctioneer role as agent for the consignor. That is a specific contractual example, not a judgement about service quality. (rmsothebys.com)
5. Have you verified that the car is available and the intermediary is authorised to offer it?
- A — 0: I have photographs, a forwarded offer or an assertion that the car is “off market”.
- B — 2: I know the vehicle identifier and reported location, but authority or current availability is not independently corroborated.
- C — 4: I have dated confirmation of availability, verified the owner or authorised representative through an independently established contact route, mapped intermediaries and disclosed fees, and confirmed inspection access.
Evidence to have: An offer-chain record showing vehicle identifier, location, who controls access, authority evidence, asking-price basis and last verification date.
Recommended control: Authorise any owner contact or disclosure of your interest in advance. Do not treat repeated circulation of an offer as verification.
6. Is there a documented route to valid ownership and title transfer?
- A — 0: I am relying on “clean title”, a registration document or seller reputation.
- B — 2: Documents have been supplied, but ownership continuity, liens, seller identity or destination-state requirements remain unresolved.
- C — 4: A suitable adviser has reviewed the applicable ownership documents and searches, reconciled vehicle and seller identities, and documented any required lien discharge and transfer steps.
Evidence to have: A title-and-ownership checklist with outstanding conditions and responsible parties.
NMVTIS can supply important title and brand-history information, but the Department of Justice warns about reporting gaps and encourages buyers to examine the relevant state title record. It also notes that some states exempt older vehicles from titling; absence of a modern title therefore needs jurisdiction-specific analysis rather than an automatic conclusion. (vehiclehistory.bja.ojp.gov)
7. Can you explain what supports the car’s identity, originality and “matching numbers” claims?
- A — 0: I accept the catalogue description, badge or certificate at face value.
- B — 2: I have factory information or photographs of identifiers, but these have not been reconciled with the physical car and its history.
- C — 4: A marque-qualified specialist has compared available factory records, physical identifiers and relevant history, with replacements, inconsistencies and limitations explicitly recorded. No unresolved identity issue undermines the purchase rationale.
Evidence to have: A component-level evidence map distinguishing documented findings, seller claims, inconsistencies and unknowns.
For Porsche, the Production Specification covers original factory configuration, while the Classic Technical Certificate includes a physical inspection and comparison of current engine and transmission information with original records. Those are different evidential products. (porsche.com)
For Mercedes-Benz, its manufacturer’s expert assessment combines examination of the vehicle with Group Archives research to assess originality and condition. Ask what was actually examined and when. (media.mercedes-benz.com)
8. Can you defend the price using relevant evidence rather than advertisements alone?
- A — 0: My reference is the seller’s price, a headline record or a general market average.
- B — 2: I have comparable listings and results, but their sale status, fee basis or specification differences are incompletely checked.
- C — 4: I have a source-linked comparison file separating asking prices, sold results, unsold lots and substantiated private transactions, with dates, currencies, fees and material differences recorded. Where evidence is thin, my decision memo says so.
Evidence to have: A price-evidence table and a written maximum offer. Do not invent numerical premiums for originality or restoration merely to bridge a gap between the evidence and the asking price.
CLASSIC.COM explicitly states that its Market Benchmark does not represent the value of a specific vehicle. Use benchmarks as context, not as a substitute for vehicle-specific comparison. (classic.com)
9. Has an independent, model-qualified inspection tested condition and restoration claims?
- A — 0: I am relying on photographs, a restoration invoice or the seller’s workshop.
- B — 2: An inspection is booked or a report exists, but its independence, scope, recency or unresolved findings are inadequate for this decision.
- C — 4: A buyer-approved specialist has completed a documented examination covering the agreed mechanical, structural and restoration scope. Findings, inspection exclusions and proposed rectification have been reviewed and reflected in the decision.
Evidence to have: A signed report, photographs, permitted test results and a prioritised work estimate. Request explicit disclosure of areas that could not be examined.
As preparation—not authentication—Porsche Club of America’s June 2026 buyer-education session includes service-history review, rebuilt-engine claims and photographs versus reality. These are useful subjects for an inspection brief, not proof about an individual car. (youtube.com)
10. Have you tested ownership costs and an inconvenient exit?
- A — 0: I expect appreciation or an easy resale to offset ownership costs.
- B — 2: I have an annual cost allowance, but no downside or delayed-sale scenario.
- C — 4: I have a multi-year cash-exposure model covering storage, insurance, servicing, expected work, transport, financing if relevant and selling costs. I have also tested a lower sale price and an additional 12 months of ownership without depending on appreciation.
Evidence to have: A workbook labelling every input as a quotation, verified charge, buyer assumption or unresolved item.
Suggested test, not a forecast: Ask whether you would still want—and could comfortably retain—the car if resale proceeds were lower than expected and sale took a year longer than planned. Choose the price reduction yourself; this quiz prescribes no universal loss assumption.
11. Is the US import, registration and intended-use route established?
- A — 0: I assume age or an existing US location settles everything.
- B — 2: One part has been checked, but federal import eligibility, engine configuration, customs treatment or destination-state requirements remain unresolved.
- C — 4: The applicable federal and state route has been reviewed for this vehicle, destination and intended use, with required documents, costs and unresolved conditions recorded. For an imported car already in the US, relevant entry documentation has been examined where applicable.
Evidence to have: A route-specific memo from the appropriate customs, registration, tax or legal specialists.
Keep three checks separate:
- NHTSA: The age-based safety exemption concerns vehicles at least 25 years old; CBP states that the period runs from manufacture. (help.cbp.gov)
- EPA: Form 3520-1 Code E uses a separate 21-year test and configuration requirements, with specific conditions for replacement engines. (epa.gov)
- State registration: California DMV expressly warns that some imported vehicles cannot be registered there. Federal eligibility is not a universal state-registration clearance. (dmv.ca.gov)
A domestic acquisition still requires the applicable title, registration and tax checks; it does not automatically earn four points.
12. Are insurance, transport, storage and maintenance ready for this particular car?
- A — 0: I will arrange ownership logistics after purchase.
- B — 2: Providers are identified, but coverage, availability, responsibility or cost remains provisional.
- C — 4: I have vehicle-specific arrangements and written confirmation of the applicable insurance start point and scope, transport responsibilities, suitable storage and maintenance support, with a named person responsible for delivery and records.
Evidence to have: An ownership handover plan, insurance confirmation and provider quotations or agreements.
Check intended use against the actual policy. Hagerty’s published qualification criteria, for example, address usage, storage and regular-use vehicles; eligibility is not determined by the car’s age alone. (hagerty.com)
13. Can you release money without relying on an email thread alone?
- A — 0: I would wire funds using instructions supplied by email.
- B — 2: I recognise the risk, but recipient verification, approval steps or handling of changed instructions remains informal.
- C — 4: The intended recipient and payment route have been verified, independent callback procedures are established, approval responsibilities are documented, and any instruction change triggers fresh verification before transfer.
Evidence to have: A payment-control checklist. Keep sensitive identity and financial documents outside the quiz and share them only through an agreed, appropriately controlled process.
The FBI recommends independently looking up contact numbers and verifying payment requests and changes through another channel. Urgency is a reason for additional scrutiny, not a reason to bypass the process. (fbi.gov)
14. Do you know exactly when the commitment becomes binding?
- A — 0: I assume a deposit is refundable or that I can withdraw after winning an auction.
- B — 2: I have read the terms, but inspection conditions, refund rights, deadlines, remedies or risk transfer remain unclear.
- C — 4: The actual transaction terms have been reviewed with suitable advice. I understand when I become bound, what conditions apply, what is refundable, which representations matter and when payment, possession and risk transfer occur.
Evidence to have: The reviewed agreement or auction conditions, plus a dated obligations checklist.
Do not wait until after bidding to investigate contractual exposure. RM Sotheby’s Monterey 2026 terms state that, subject to the contractual obligations, the bill of sale is concluded and irrevocable at the close of the lot. (rmsothebys.com)
15. Will you walk away if the evidence fails to support the purchase?
- A — 0: I would probably proceed to avoid losing a rare opportunity or wasting work already paid for.
- B — 2: I have concerns and a nominal ceiling, but no written rules for unresolved issues or exceptions.
- C — 4: I have a written maximum all-in exposure, explicit rejection criteria and a decision memo separating facts from assumptions. An authorised decision-maker must approve exceptions, and “do not buy” remains an acceptable outcome.
Evidence to have: A short proceed, renegotiate, investigate or decline memo. Record unresolved matters and their consequences rather than making them disappear inside an overall positive recommendation.
Sources cited on this page
- rmsothebys.comrmsothebys.com
- vehiclehistory.bja.ojp.govvehiclehistory.bja.ojp.gov
- porsche.comporsche.com
- media.mercedes-benz.commedia.mercedes-benz.com
- classic.comclassic.com
- youtube.comyoutube.com
- help.cbp.govhelp.cbp.gov
- epa.govepa.gov
- dmv.ca.govdmv.ca.gov
- hagerty.comhagerty.com
- fbi.govfbi.gov
