Section 09 of 12 / Briefings & media

Scorecard

Score an adviser or a car and plan against weighted criteria.

Pages
16
Sources cited
19
Last updated
17 Nov 2026
A1. Independence and conflict controlWeight 20
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
Unclear representation; undisclosed referral income, inventory interests or success incentives
Adequate: 3
Written representation and fee disclosures; conflicts identified, with a credible separation plan
Strong: 5
Buyer-controlled mandate; all economic interests mapped; independent specialists; no undisclosed seller compensation; documented ability to recommend no purchase
A2. Exact-model competenceWeight 20
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
Generic luxury-car experience; reputation substituted for named expertise
Adequate: 3
Named marque specialist, relevant sample work and a model-specific investigation plan
Strong: 5
Comparable assignments substantiated with permission; appropriate archive and physical-inspection expertise; clear escalation for identity disputes; reporting limitations demonstrated
A3. Access and authority-verification disciplineWeight 15
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
Recycled listings or claims of exclusive access without a verifiable route
Adequate: 3
A workable process for confirming location, availability and intermediary roles
Strong: 5
Demonstrated authority-check workflow; dated owner-side confirmation; duplicate-offer controls; buyer-approved outreach and a precise definition of verified availability
A4. Research and valuation qualityWeight 15
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
Asking prices treated as sales; unsupported originality premiums; no source trail
Adequate: 3
Source-linked report distinguishing sold, unsold and asking evidence; clear comparable exclusions
Strong: 5
Vehicle-level evidence register, archived sources, correct price bases, counter-evidence and transparent limits on private-sale data
A5. Execution and specialist coordinationWeight 15
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
One person informally promises to handle inspection, legal work and import
Adequate: 3
Named specialists, budget and timetable; tasks allocated
Strong: 5
Written responsibilities, accepted scopes, dependencies and backup arrangements; clear expenditure authority and escalation; qualifications and relevant insurance checked
A6. Confidentiality and information controlWeight 10
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
Unrestricted forwarding; buyer identity circulated without permission
Adequate: 3
Confidentiality terms, controlled sharing and retention policy
Strong: 5
Permissioned evidence room, access records, redacted initial outreach, explicit subcontractor controls and agreed restrictions on AI processing or training
A7. Commercial clarity and accountabilityWeight 5
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
Open-ended charges, vague outputs or fees payable on ambiguous triggers
Adequate: 3
Defined deliverables, expenses and cancellation terms
Strong: 5
Milestone-based acceptance; approved cost caps; explicit success-fee triggers, exclusivity and tail provisions; usable records delivered even if no car is bought

Rate each criterion 0–5 against the anchors; weighted score = weight × rating ÷ 5. Gates and evidence caps in the research apply separately.

Proposed procurement criteria and weights, not an industry standard.

Every page in this section

  1. 01What should a classic car acquisition scorecard actually decide?Score the acquisition team and the proposed purchase separately.Read →
  2. 02Which supplier should be assessed—and in what role?Assess the proposed buyer side lead and its complete delivery team, not every seller as though it were an independent adviser.Read →
  3. 03How should the scoring work?Award points for demonstrated capability and decision ready evidence—not confidence, prestige or document volume.Read →
  4. 04Which issues override the weighted score?The following are proposed non negotiable gates.Read →
  5. 05Scorecard A: How should we judge a classic car buying adviser?Give the most weight to independence and model specific competence.Read →
  6. 06Scorecard B: How should we judge the car and acquisition plan?The largest weight belongs to identity and provenance, followed by ownership, condition and price evidence.Read →
  7. 07What should a Mercedes-Benz 300 SL pre-purchase inspection brief include?Require component level identity work and a separate assessment of condition and restoration.Read →
  8. 08How should Porsche Turbo and RS authenticity be assessed?Begin with the exact factory variant, then reconcile the present car with its records.Read →
  9. 09How should classic car auction prices be compared with dealer asking prices?Use a consistent price basis and preserve the distinction between an offer and a reported transaction.Read →
  10. 10What must the US import, title and registration review establish?Treat federal safety, federal emissions, customs treatment and state registration as separate workstreams.Read →
  11. 11How should ownership costs and resale risk affect the score?Score the completeness and affordability of the plan, not a forecast of appreciation.Read →
  12. 12What does a worked scoring example look like?A credible team can still produce a purchase that is not ready.Read →
  13. 13What belongs in the before-the-deposit decision pack?The final output should be an executable decision, not merely a score.Read →
  14. 14What should the investment director sign?Use a short approval statement: We recommend [proceed / renegotiate / investigate further / decline] for vehicle [reference]. Supplier/team score: [A]/100.Read →

Research quality

buyer fit
9/10
depth
9/10
search terms
8/10
sources
9/10

Explore the research