Market data and deal flow

How should auction prices be compared with dealer asking prices?

The Vintage Vault research deskSection 11Page 7 of 12Last updated 17 Nov 2026

Normalise the price basis before making any condition adjustment. A dealer’s asking price, a winning bid and an auction house’s published result can represent different cash amounts.

Price fieldRecommended treatment
Auction hammer or online winning bidAdd the applicable buyer fee; retain the original bid separately.
Published buyer-inclusive resultDo not add the premium a second time. Record excluded taxes and costs.
Pre-sale estimateKeep outside the completed-sales dataset. Compare with hammer, not automatically with premium-inclusive results.
Dealer asking priceLabel as an offer; record disclosed fees, price changes and observation dates.
Verified private considerationRecord documentary basis, currency, date, commissions and any part-exchange component.
Unsold or withdrawn offeringPreserve the outcome. Do not turn an estimate or unaccepted bid into a sale.

The distinction is explicit in current auction terms: RM’s Monterey bidder information separates hammer, premium and taxes, while Gooding’s conditions exclude premium and taxes from estimates. (fe2.rmsothebys.com)

What does the buyer’s premium do to the budget?

For RM Sotheby’s 13–15 August 2026 Monterey sale, the published motor-car premium was 12% on the first $250,000 of hammer and 10% on the balance. Therefore an illustrative $1.5m hammer produces $155,000 of premium and $1.655m before taxes, transport or other costs. This is a calculation from that event’s schedule, not a universal auction tariff. (fe2.rmsothebys.com)

For illustration, if a buyer sets a $2m total cap and reserves $100,000 for all non-auction costs, the same schedule allows a maximum hammer of approximately $1,722,727:

Maximum hammer = ($2,000,000 − $100,000 − $5,000) ÷ 1.10

The $100,000 allowance is an arbitrary scenario input, not an estimate of actual taxes or ownership costs. Replace it with destination-specific advice and written quotations before bidding. (fe2.rmsothebys.com)

Sources cited on this page

  1. fe2.rmsothebys.comfe2.rmsothebys.com

Explore the research