Comparisons

10. How should ownership cost and resale risk change the comparison?

The Vintage Vault research deskSection 03Page 11 of 13Last updated 17 Nov 2026

Compare net ownership expenditure under explicit scenarios, not just entry prices or an assumed resale gain. The following example is a planning exercise, not a maintenance quote, selling-fee benchmark or prediction.

Assumptions: $1.2 million initial all-in expenditure; $20,000 annual carrying costs; and an illustrative 6% selling charge. There is no financing, inflation, investment-opportunity cost or tax-on-disposal calculation.

ScenarioHolding periodGross resale assumptionNet resale after assumed selling chargeTotal net ownership expenditure
Base planning case5 years$1,000,000$940,000$360,000
Lower resale case5 years$800,000$752,000$548,000
Lower resale plus delay6 years$800,000$752,000$568,000

Net ownership expenditure = initial all-in expenditure + carrying costs − net resale proceeds

Replace every assumption with the buyer’s actual quotes and scenarios. Keep initial rectification, routine servicing, major work, storage, insurance, transport and financing in separate lines so that an attractive purchase price cannot conceal an incomplete budget.

For exit planning, our recommended comparison is:

Proposed exit routeEvidence to obtain before relying on it
Dealer purchaseA current written acquisition indication and its inspection conditions—not the dealer’s retail advertisement
Dealer or broker consignmentProposed asking strategy, fee schedule, exclusivity, expenditure authority and termination terms
AuctionConsignment terms, reserve strategy, transport and preparation costs, and treatment of an unsold car
Direct private saleA realistic plan for buyer qualification, inspections, documentation and secure completion

Do not turn these options into promised liquidation periods. Record which counterparties have actually expressed interest and whether that interest is documented, conditional or merely conversational.

Explore the research