Comparisons

2. How should you compare a classic car broker with a buyer representative?

The Vintage Vault research deskSection 03Page 3 of 13Last updated 17 Nov 2026

Compare the written mandate, not the job title. Our proposed test for buyer representation is whether the adviser must investigate adverse evidence, disclose competing interests and recommend declining the car when appropriate.

The following are contract structures to negotiate, not claims about prevailing market tariffs:

Fee structureUseful featureIncentive or scope issueRecommended contractual protection
Fixed research feeDefined expenditure for an evidence-based decision, including a decision not to buyA vague scope may produce an attractive report without resolving the buyer’s questionsSpecify candidates, research questions, deliverables, exclusions and revision limits
Hourly or staged diligenceFlexible where archive research or ownership history is uncertainExpenditure can expand before the buyer receives a decisionSet approval caps, progress checkpoints and stop-work triggers
Percentage success feeLinks payment to completionRemuneration increases with transaction value and depends on a purchase occurringDefine the fee base, cap, termination rights and treatment of previously known cars
Fixed fee plus completion feeSeparates research work from transaction executionThe completion incentive remainsRequire disclosure and approval of each component before sourcing begins

No defensible universal buying-agent fee was established in this research. Obtain competing written scopes in dollars rather than treating a broad percentage range as a tariff. Ask whether the quoted fee includes negotiation, travel, inspection coordination, title work and post-purchase administration—or merely an introduction.

A useful engagement letter should answer five questions:

  1. Who is the client?
  2. Who else can pay the adviser?
  3. What happens if no purchase occurs?
  4. Which conclusions require a separately appointed specialist?
  5. Who owns and may reuse the research and vehicle records?

Explore the research