Comparisons

6. Can a higher dealer price be cheaper than an auction purchase?

The Vintage Vault research deskSection 03Page 7 of 13Last updated 17 Nov 2026

Yes—once the prices are put on the same basis. RM Sotheby’s published Monterey 2026 terms specify a motor-car buyer’s premium of 12% on the first $250,000 and 10% above that amount. Gooding Christie’s published US live-auction terms use the same tiers, while its online-only vehicle premium is 10%. These are specific published terms, not universal auction rates. (rmsothebys.com)

Worked comparison: a hypothetical $1 million hammer price

The vehicle prices below are illustrative. Only the premium calculation uses the cited published tier structure.

ItemHypothetical negotiated purchaseHypothetical auction purchase
Agreed vehicle price / hammer$1,080,000$1,000,000
Additional buyer premium assumed$0$105,000
Vehicle acquisition amount before other costs$1,080,000$1,105,000

The auction calculation is $30,000 on the first $250,000 plus $75,000 on the remaining $750,000. On these assumptions, the apparently higher negotiated price is $25,000 lower before tax, diligence, transport and preparation.

This does not demonstrate that dealers are cheaper. It demonstrates why comparing an asking price with a hammer price is analytically wrong.

For that tier structure, when hammer exceeds $250,000:

Hammer plus premium = 1.10 × hammer + $5,000

If $1,105,000 remains after reserving every other acquisition cost, the corresponding hammer ceiling is $1 million. Have the office calculate and approve the actual ceiling using the applicable event terms, tax advice and quotes before bidding.

Sources cited on this page

  1. rmsothebys.comrmsothebys.com

Explore the research