Scorecard

Which issues override the weighted score?

The Vintage Vault research deskSection 09Page 4 of 16Last updated 17 Nov 2026

The following are proposed non-negotiable gates. Mark each Pass, Hold or Fail, with a named reviewer and dated evidence. Hold means further work is possible; Fail means the current proposal is unacceptable unless materially changed.

GateWhat is required to pass?What stops progress?
G1. Adviser identity, role and conflictsVerified contracting entity, authorised signatory, written scope and complete compensation disclosureUnverified entity, concealed interests or an adviser presented as independent while acting for the seller
G2. Seller authority and availabilityA traceable route to the owner or authorised representative, verified authority and current transaction statusAn intermediary chain that cannot establish who may sell or accept money
G3. Vehicle identity and inspectionMaterial identity claims reconciled; buyer-appointed inspection completed to an agreed scopeUnresolved chassis identity, unexplained material markings or refusal of necessary inspection
G4. Ownership and lawful intended useCounsel-approved transfer route; relevant encumbrances addressed; documented import and registration pathway where applicableUnresolved ownership dispute, unacceptable lien exposure or no supported route to intended use
G5. Contract and payment controlsApproved contract, beneficiary verification, agreed release conditions and insurance arrangementsUnexplained third-party payment destination, unverified bank change or unacceptable unconditional payment demand
G6. Mandate and expenditureCar meets the approved brief; initial and ownership expenditure are authorisedUnapproved budget excess or a fundamental mismatch with the principal’s intended use

G1 applies before appointing the adviser. G2–G6 apply before an unconditional vehicle commitment, including a non-refundable deposit or binding bid. A limited diligence engagement is not purchase approval. Any refundable reservation needs its own legal review of enforceability, custody and refund conditions.

At auction, do not assume a post-bid inspection escape route. Gooding Christie’s published conditions state that bids are binding and irrevocable, with a purchase contract formed when the bid is accepted at the fall of the hammer. (goodingco.com)

Sources cited on this page

  1. goodingco.comgoodingco.com

Explore the research