Scorecard

What does a worked scoring example look like?

The Vintage Vault research deskSection 09Page 12 of 16Last updated 17 Nov 2026

A credible team can still produce a purchase that is not ready. The following example is invented solely to demonstrate the method; it describes no actual supplier or vehicle.

A family office is considering an overseas 993 Turbo S. The adviser’s A1–A7 ratings are 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 4, producing 86/100 with full evidence coverage and a passed appointment gate.

The initial vehicle assessment is different:

CriterionWeightInitial ratingInitial pointsAfter remediation: ratingRevised points
B1 Identity and provenance20520520
B2 Ownership and authority15412412
B3 Condition15412412
B4 Price evidence1539412
B5 Import and registration100048
B6 Cash exposure104848
B7 Contract and payment1000510
B8 Use and exit54444
Total1006586

Initially, B5 and B7 are U: the destination-state route and payment arrangements remain unverified. Coverage is 80%, and G4 and G5 are Hold. Decision: authorise only the next diligence stage, not an unconditional purchase.

In the hypothetical remediation, appropriate specialists establish the route, counsel approves completion arrangements, the beneficiary is independently verified, and the valuation file is strengthened. The score becomes 86 with 100% coverage. It is now eligible for human approval—not automatically approved.

Explore the research