Use a consistent price basis and preserve the distinction between an offer and a reported transaction. Never fill an unknown fee basis with a convenient assumption.
Two public Porsche observations illustrate the required discipline:
| Observation | Published figure | What it establishes | What remains unproven |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gooding Christie’s Amelia Island 2025, 1997 993 Turbo S, chassis ending 375725 | $643,000 reported sold result | The auction house reports that result; its description records just over 14,400 miles at cataloguing. (goodingco.com) | The underlying settlement has not been reviewed; event-specific fee treatment must be retained before normalisation |
| Isringhausen Imports listing, 1997 993 Turbo S, chassis ending 375839 | $899,900 advertised total excluding taxes | The listing separates $899,488 vehicle price and $412 disclosed dealer fees, and states 26,440 miles. (isringhausen.porsche.com) | Current availability, negotiated consideration and vehicle claims have not been independently confirmed |
These observations do not establish a market range or prove either car is mispriced. The second is not a completed sale, and the cars require individual comparison.
For each comparable, require:
- Full vehicle identity and duplicate-listing check.
- Exact variant, specification and market of original delivery.
- Sale date, location, currency and source observation date.
- Sold, unsold, withdrawn, advertised or privately reported status.
- Hammer, buyer-inclusive or otherwise specified price basis.
- Condition, restoration, provenance and material amendments.
- Inclusion or exclusion rationale.
- Currency-conversion source and date, where needed.
For fee arithmetic, Gooding Christie’s published US live-auction vehicle terms specify 12% on the first $250,000 and 10% above that. Under that schedule, a hypothetical $1 million hammer becomes $1.105 million before taxes and other expenditure. Recheck the terms applicable to the actual event. (goodingco.com)
Thin evidence rule: if the observations do not support a defensible range, say so. The buyer may still consider a discretionary collecting premium, but it must be separately identified and approved—not disguised as market evidence.
Sources cited on this page
- goodingco.comgoodingco.com
- isringhausen.porsche.comisringhausen.porsche.com
- goodingco.comgoodingco.com
