Scorecard

Scorecard A: How should we judge a classic car buying adviser?

The Vintage Vault research deskSection 09Page 5 of 16Last updated 17 Nov 2026
A1. Independence and conflict controlWeight 20
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
Unclear representation; undisclosed referral income, inventory interests or success incentives
Adequate: 3
Written representation and fee disclosures; conflicts identified, with a credible separation plan
Strong: 5
Buyer-controlled mandate; all economic interests mapped; independent specialists; no undisclosed seller compensation; documented ability to recommend no purchase
A2. Exact-model competenceWeight 20
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
Generic luxury-car experience; reputation substituted for named expertise
Adequate: 3
Named marque specialist, relevant sample work and a model-specific investigation plan
Strong: 5
Comparable assignments substantiated with permission; appropriate archive and physical-inspection expertise; clear escalation for identity disputes; reporting limitations demonstrated
A3. Access and authority-verification disciplineWeight 15
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
Recycled listings or claims of exclusive access without a verifiable route
Adequate: 3
A workable process for confirming location, availability and intermediary roles
Strong: 5
Demonstrated authority-check workflow; dated owner-side confirmation; duplicate-offer controls; buyer-approved outreach and a precise definition of verified availability
A4. Research and valuation qualityWeight 15
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
Asking prices treated as sales; unsupported originality premiums; no source trail
Adequate: 3
Source-linked report distinguishing sold, unsold and asking evidence; clear comparable exclusions
Strong: 5
Vehicle-level evidence register, archived sources, correct price bases, counter-evidence and transparent limits on private-sale data
A5. Execution and specialist coordinationWeight 15
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
One person informally promises to handle inspection, legal work and import
Adequate: 3
Named specialists, budget and timetable; tasks allocated
Strong: 5
Written responsibilities, accepted scopes, dependencies and backup arrangements; clear expenditure authority and escalation; qualifications and relevant insurance checked
A6. Confidentiality and information controlWeight 10
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
Unrestricted forwarding; buyer identity circulated without permission
Adequate: 3
Confidentiality terms, controlled sharing and retention policy
Strong: 5
Permissioned evidence room, access records, redacted initial outreach, explicit subcontractor controls and agreed restrictions on AI processing or training
A7. Commercial clarity and accountabilityWeight 5
Anchors
Weak: 0–1
Open-ended charges, vague outputs or fees payable on ambiguous triggers
Adequate: 3
Defined deliverables, expenses and cancellation terms
Strong: 5
Milestone-based acceptance; approved cost caps; explicit success-fee triggers, exclusivity and tail provisions; usable records delivered even if no car is bought

Rate each criterion 0–5 against the anchors; weighted score = weight × rating ÷ 5. Gates and evidence caps in the research apply separately.

Give the most weight to independence and model-specific competence. Access matters, but access without disciplined verification is not enough for a buyer-side mandate.

The following anchors are proposed procurement requirements. Apply the evidence caps above as well as the row descriptions.

CriterionWeightWeak: 0–1Adequate: 3Strong: 5
A1. Independence and conflict control20Unclear representation; undisclosed referral income, inventory interests or success incentivesWritten representation and fee disclosures; conflicts identified, with a credible separation planBuyer-controlled mandate; all economic interests mapped; independent specialists; no undisclosed seller compensation; documented ability to recommend no purchase
A2. Exact-model competence20Generic luxury-car experience; reputation substituted for named expertiseNamed marque specialist, relevant sample work and a model-specific investigation planComparable assignments substantiated with permission; appropriate archive and physical-inspection expertise; clear escalation for identity disputes; reporting limitations demonstrated
A3. Access and authority-verification discipline15Recycled listings or claims of exclusive access without a verifiable routeA workable process for confirming location, availability and intermediary rolesDemonstrated authority-check workflow; dated owner-side confirmation; duplicate-offer controls; buyer-approved outreach and a precise definition of verified availability
A4. Research and valuation quality15Asking prices treated as sales; unsupported originality premiums; no source trailSource-linked report distinguishing sold, unsold and asking evidence; clear comparable exclusionsVehicle-level evidence register, archived sources, correct price bases, counter-evidence and transparent limits on private-sale data
A5. Execution and specialist coordination15One person informally promises to handle inspection, legal work and importNamed specialists, budget and timetable; tasks allocatedWritten responsibilities, accepted scopes, dependencies and backup arrangements; clear expenditure authority and escalation; qualifications and relevant insurance checked
A6. Confidentiality and information control10Unrestricted forwarding; buyer identity circulated without permissionConfidentiality terms, controlled sharing and retention policyPermissioned evidence room, access records, redacted initial outreach, explicit subcontractor controls and agreed restrictions on AI processing or training
A7. Commercial clarity and accountability5Open-ended charges, vague outputs or fees payable on ambiguous triggersDefined deliverables, expenses and cancellation termsMilestone-based acceptance; approved cost caps; explicit success-fee triggers, exclusivity and tail provisions; usable records delivered even if no car is bought
Total100

What should the adviser demonstrate before appointment?

Request a redacted sample containing:

  1. A claim-to-source evidence register.
  2. An example where the recommendation was to decline or investigate further.
  3. A comparable-sales table with exclusions and price-basis notes.
  4. A model-specific inspection brief, including what was not tested.
  5. A transaction responsibility matrix and completed decision memo.

Suggested appointment policy: prefer candidates scoring at least 85, with evidence coverage of at least 90%, no failed gate, no row below three, and A1 and A2 each at least four. A score of 70–84 warrants a remediation discussion; below 70 indicates an unsuitable or insufficiently evidenced full-service proposal.

A seller-owned workshop can contribute useful records. Under this policy, it should not be the sole independent reviewer of its own restoration work.

Explore the research