Anchors
- Weak: 0–1
- Unclear representation; undisclosed referral income, inventory interests or success incentives
- Adequate: 3
- Written representation and fee disclosures; conflicts identified, with a credible separation plan
- Strong: 5
- Buyer-controlled mandate; all economic interests mapped; independent specialists; no undisclosed seller compensation; documented ability to recommend no purchase
Anchors
- Weak: 0–1
- Generic luxury-car experience; reputation substituted for named expertise
- Adequate: 3
- Named marque specialist, relevant sample work and a model-specific investigation plan
- Strong: 5
- Comparable assignments substantiated with permission; appropriate archive and physical-inspection expertise; clear escalation for identity disputes; reporting limitations demonstrated
Anchors
- Weak: 0–1
- Recycled listings or claims of exclusive access without a verifiable route
- Adequate: 3
- A workable process for confirming location, availability and intermediary roles
- Strong: 5
- Demonstrated authority-check workflow; dated owner-side confirmation; duplicate-offer controls; buyer-approved outreach and a precise definition of verified availability
Anchors
- Weak: 0–1
- Asking prices treated as sales; unsupported originality premiums; no source trail
- Adequate: 3
- Source-linked report distinguishing sold, unsold and asking evidence; clear comparable exclusions
- Strong: 5
- Vehicle-level evidence register, archived sources, correct price bases, counter-evidence and transparent limits on private-sale data
Anchors
- Weak: 0–1
- One person informally promises to handle inspection, legal work and import
- Adequate: 3
- Named specialists, budget and timetable; tasks allocated
- Strong: 5
- Written responsibilities, accepted scopes, dependencies and backup arrangements; clear expenditure authority and escalation; qualifications and relevant insurance checked
Anchors
- Weak: 0–1
- Unrestricted forwarding; buyer identity circulated without permission
- Adequate: 3
- Confidentiality terms, controlled sharing and retention policy
- Strong: 5
- Permissioned evidence room, access records, redacted initial outreach, explicit subcontractor controls and agreed restrictions on AI processing or training
Anchors
- Weak: 0–1
- Open-ended charges, vague outputs or fees payable on ambiguous triggers
- Adequate: 3
- Defined deliverables, expenses and cancellation terms
- Strong: 5
- Milestone-based acceptance; approved cost caps; explicit success-fee triggers, exclusivity and tail provisions; usable records delivered even if no car is bought
Rate each criterion 0–5 against the anchors; weighted score = weight × rating ÷ 5. Gates and evidence caps in the research apply separately.
Give the most weight to independence and model-specific competence. Access matters, but access without disciplined verification is not enough for a buyer-side mandate.
The following anchors are proposed procurement requirements. Apply the evidence caps above as well as the row descriptions.
| Criterion | Weight | Weak: 0–1 | Adequate: 3 | Strong: 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1. Independence and conflict control | 20 | Unclear representation; undisclosed referral income, inventory interests or success incentives | Written representation and fee disclosures; conflicts identified, with a credible separation plan | Buyer-controlled mandate; all economic interests mapped; independent specialists; no undisclosed seller compensation; documented ability to recommend no purchase |
| A2. Exact-model competence | 20 | Generic luxury-car experience; reputation substituted for named expertise | Named marque specialist, relevant sample work and a model-specific investigation plan | Comparable assignments substantiated with permission; appropriate archive and physical-inspection expertise; clear escalation for identity disputes; reporting limitations demonstrated |
| A3. Access and authority-verification discipline | 15 | Recycled listings or claims of exclusive access without a verifiable route | A workable process for confirming location, availability and intermediary roles | Demonstrated authority-check workflow; dated owner-side confirmation; duplicate-offer controls; buyer-approved outreach and a precise definition of verified availability |
| A4. Research and valuation quality | 15 | Asking prices treated as sales; unsupported originality premiums; no source trail | Source-linked report distinguishing sold, unsold and asking evidence; clear comparable exclusions | Vehicle-level evidence register, archived sources, correct price bases, counter-evidence and transparent limits on private-sale data |
| A5. Execution and specialist coordination | 15 | One person informally promises to handle inspection, legal work and import | Named specialists, budget and timetable; tasks allocated | Written responsibilities, accepted scopes, dependencies and backup arrangements; clear expenditure authority and escalation; qualifications and relevant insurance checked |
| A6. Confidentiality and information control | 10 | Unrestricted forwarding; buyer identity circulated without permission | Confidentiality terms, controlled sharing and retention policy | Permissioned evidence room, access records, redacted initial outreach, explicit subcontractor controls and agreed restrictions on AI processing or training |
| A7. Commercial clarity and accountability | 5 | Open-ended charges, vague outputs or fees payable on ambiguous triggers | Defined deliverables, expenses and cancellation terms | Milestone-based acceptance; approved cost caps; explicit success-fee triggers, exclusivity and tail provisions; usable records delivered even if no car is bought |
| Total | 100 |
What should the adviser demonstrate before appointment?
Request a redacted sample containing:
- A claim-to-source evidence register.
- An example where the recommendation was to decline or investigate further.
- A comparable-sales table with exclusions and price-basis notes.
- A model-specific inspection brief, including what was not tested.
- A transaction responsibility matrix and completed decision memo.
Suggested appointment policy: prefer candidates scoring at least 85, with evidence coverage of at least 90%, no failed gate, no row below three, and A1 and A2 each at least four. A score of 70–84 warrants a remediation discussion; below 70 indicates an unsuitable or insufficiently evidenced full-service proposal.
A seller-owned workshop can contribute useful records. Under this policy, it should not be the sole independent reviewer of its own restoration work.
