Assess the proposed buyer-side lead and its complete delivery team, not every seller as though it were an independent adviser. A dealer can be an acceptable selling counterparty without qualifying as the buyer’s independent representative.
Write down whether each participant is an inventory owner, seller’s agent, introducer, buyer’s representative, inspector, restorer or transaction specialist. Ask separately who pays it and whether it has an economic interest in the car.
The distinction is substantive. An RM Sotheby’s recruitment page describes its private-sales activities as encompassing principal trades, off-market brokerage and consignments, alongside responsibilities for generating revenue. That is evidence of several possible commercial roles—not evidence of misconduct, and not a substitute for establishing the role in an individual transaction. (job-boards.greenhouse.io)
| Decision | Use | Do not infer |
|---|---|---|
| Appoint a buyer’s acquisition adviser | Scorecard A, with a named specialist team and written responsibilities | That every car the adviser finds is suitable |
| Approve a particular car | Scorecard B, after vehicle-specific investigation | That the seller becomes an independent adviser |
| Buy a narrow service, such as an inspection | Evaluate the relevant specialist’s scope and evidence; assess the remaining work at team level | That an inspector is responsible for title, tax or payment unless expressly engaged |
| Compare two seller channels | Compare their actual offers, authority, terms and evidence through Scorecard B | That a lower commission outweighs weaker transaction protection |
For licensing, obtain advice for the actual activities and states involved. California, for example, states that vehicle dealers need an autobroker’s endorsement to broker retail sales transactions; that example should not be generalised into a national licensing conclusion. (dmv.ca.gov)
Sources cited on this page
- job-boards.greenhouse.iojob-boards.greenhouse.io
- dmv.ca.govdmv.ca.gov
