The final output should be an executable decision, not merely a score. Use the following checklist as the proposed minimum committee pack.
- Approved brief: exact variant, use, originality requirements, destination state and maximum all-in expenditure.
- Scorecard A and Scorecard B, with evidence statuses and explanations.
- Gate register identifying each reviewer and unresolved condition.
- Current owner-side availability and authority confirmation.
- Identity/provenance matrix and independent inspection report, including limitations.
- Comparable-sales file and maximum payable price on the correct fee basis.
- Initial cash requirement, ownership assumptions, contingency and exit sensitivities.
- Counsel-approved contract and completion instructions.
- Payment-verification record, authorisations and insurance effective-time confirmation.
- Handover inventory covering the car, keys, documents, tools, luggage and other agreed items.
The last item is not cosmetic administration. Gooding Christie’s 2025 Turbo S lot carried a saleroom amendment correcting its description: a jack accompanied the car, but the advertised tools did not. (goodingco.com)
How should payment instructions be controlled?
The FBI recommends independently obtaining contact details, verifying payment requests and confirming changes to account numbers or payment procedures. (fbi.gov)
The desk’s proposed implementation is:
- Independently verify the receiving party and payment purpose.
- Confirm instructions using a trusted contact route—not contact details supplied only in the payment-change message.
- Require a second authorised reviewer for the payment pack.
- Stop and repeat verification after any change.
- Use counsel-approved custody and release arrangements appropriate to the transaction; an escrow label alone earns no points.
Gooding Christie’s conditions also illustrate why insurance timing needs explicit review: they allocate risk of loss to the buyer at the fall of the hammer. Do not assume risk begins only when the transporter collects the car. (goodingco.com)
When should a score expire?
Under this proposed policy, reopen affected rows whenever price, location, ownership, condition, intermediary, bank details, legal route or transaction terms change. Reconfirm availability and authority before commitment, and payment instructions immediately before transfer.
Retain the prior score and evidence version. Record what changed and who approved the revision. A high score must not survive a material change merely because a PDF has already been issued.
Sources cited on this page
- goodingco.comgoodingco.com
- fbi.govfbi.gov
- goodingco.comgoodingco.com
