Scorecard

How should the scoring work?

The Vintage Vault research deskSection 09Page 3 of 16Last updated 17 Nov 2026

Award points for demonstrated capability and decision-ready evidence—not confidence, prestige or document volume. Freeze the acquisition brief and weights before comparing candidates.

What does each numerical rating mean?

RatingGeneral interpretation
0Required evidence is absent, a material contradiction remains unresolved, or a verified finding makes the proposal unacceptable
1Primarily assertions, marketing material or an untested promise
2Some relevant evidence, but important corroboration, scope or responsibilities remain incomplete
3An adequate, traceable basis exists; limitations and remaining actions are explicit
4Strong, independently checked evidence; only bounded, non-critical limitations remain
5The requirement is fully addressed for this mandate, with corroboration, explicit limitations and a practical execution plan

A five does not mean perfect originality or zero mechanical risk. A fully documented replacement gearbox could be acceptable for a driving-focused brief but unacceptable for a brief requiring original major components.

Weighted points = criterion weight × rating ÷ 5.

For example, a rating of four on a 15-point criterion earns 12 points. Use whole-number ratings and explain every rating in one or two sentences.

How should missing evidence be distinguished from adverse evidence?

Attach an evidence status to every row:

StatusMeaningScoring restriction
V — Independently checkedThe material claims have been corroborated through suitable original sources or independent specialist workEligible for 0–5, according to the finding
D — DocumentedRelevant records have been obtained and their source identified, but necessary independent corroboration is incompleteMaximum 3
C — ClaimedSeller or supplier assertion without adequate supporting evidenceMaximum 1
U — UnknownRequired information has not been supplied or established0 until resolved
X — InconsistentMaterial sources conflict and the conflict remains unresolved0 until resolved

Unknown is not an accusation. A verified adverse finding may have status V and still score zero. Conversely, a large file of uncorroborated documents should not automatically receive V.

For a row covering several material claims, use the weakest unresolved material status. Do not downgrade a row because an immaterial accessory receipt is missing; record that separately.

Report evidence coverage alongside the score: the sum of weights of rows marked D or V, divided by 100. Coverage measures how much has a documented basis, not how favourable the findings are.

Do not remove difficult rows or redistribute their weights. For a domestic purchase, the import-and-registration row still requires an assessment of applicable title, registration, tax and any relevant prior-import documentation.

Explore the research